Online dating ad banned after scientific claims were dismissed as ‘fake news’

An advert for an online dating service has been banned after its scientific claims were dismissed as little more than “fake news”.

The billboard advert for  eHarmony claimed it uses a “scientifically proven matching system”.

However, the Advertising Standards Agency (ASA) said the service could offer no evidence that customers had a significantly greater chance of finding lasting love.

Lord Lipsey, who lodged the complaint and is joint chairman of the All Party Parliamentary Group on Statistics and a former lay member of the Advertising Standards Authority’s (ASA) council, said: “Phrases like ‘scientifically proven’ should be confined to claims that are just that, not used in crude puffery designed to lure in those longing for love.

“This is a new form of fake news which the ASA has rightly slapped down.”

The advert, placed on a London Underground platform, said: “Step aside, fate. It’s time science had a go at love.”

It went on: “Imagine being able to stack the odds of finding lasting love entirely in your favour. EHarmony’s scientifically proven matching system decodes the mystery of compatibility and chemistry so you don’t have to. Why leave the most important search of your life to chance?”

The website said it used an algorithm based on scientific theories in the relationship literature of assortative mating that required users to complete lengthy questionnaires to determine their personality traits, values, interests and other factors.

Users were then matched to other individuals whose responses complemented their own preferences and matched a specific percentage of a list of personality factors that eHarmony determined to be vital in successfully matching people.

The ASA said consumers would interpret the claim “scientifically proven matching system” to mean that scientific studies had found that the website offered users a significantly greater chance of finding lasting love than what could be achieved if they did not use the service.

It noted that neither of the studies provided by eHarmony revealed anything about the overall percentage of its users who had found lasting love after using the website compared to other sources.

Therefore, neither study provided insight into the likelihood of the website finding users lasting love compared to users who did not use the service.

The ASA said: “Because the evidence provided by eHarmony did not demonstrate that their matching system offered users a significantly greater chance of finding lasting love than what could be achieved if they didn’t use the service, we concluded that the claim ‘scientifically proven matching system’ was misleading.”

Romain Bertrand, managing director at eHarmony UK, said: “eHarmony was conceived on the premise that science and research could be harnessed to help people find love. For over 17 years, eharmony has been matching singles into high-quality, long-lasting relationships based upon sophisticated matching standards designed by PhD psychologists.

“Although we respectfully disagree with the ASA’s findings, we are happy to work with them to assure that our advertising is as clear as possible.”

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s