Psychology: IQ tests – a matter of life or death?

Cross-section scan of a human brain
Innocent until proven intelligent?

Lawyers recently challenged the use of a fixed IQ threshold to determine a convict’s fate

A few dropped marks in an IQ test is no big deal – unless you’re on Death Row. US federal law bans the death penalty for the “intellectually disabled”; several American states use an IQ score of 70 as the qualifying criterion, with inmates scoring above that facing execution (70 is two standard deviations below the mean score of 100). Recently, lawyers successfully challenged the use of a fixed IQ threshold to determine a convict’s fate, arguing that the science of intelligence testing is imprecise and that IQ tests alone could not determine mental competence.

The 5-4 ruling by the US Supreme Court centred on the case of Freddie Lee Hall, a double murderer who has been on Death Row for 36 years. After numerous tests yielding scores between 60 and 80, reported the journal Nature, Hall was finally assigned an IQ of 71. The state of Florida wanted to execute him; his lawyers argued, with backing from the American Psychological Association, that any score has an error margin of five points either way. The Supreme Court ruled in Hall’s favour, saying that Florida could not use IQ as the “final and conclusive” measure of intellectual ability. The ruling could prompt a flood of appeals.

James Harris, a psychiatrist at Johns Hopkins University in Maryland, told the journal that courts should scrap outdated IQ assessments in favour of tests for “adaptive functioning”, which measure impulse control, empathy and social skills. The APA is now advocating a new definition of intellectual disability that reflects current scientific thinking on intelligence.

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Advertisements
UptightPrettyGirl

Have fun reading. Message me any time.

Slippery Edge

beauty is in the eye of the beholder

nicolesundays

humor. storytelling. general stupidity.

unbolt me

the literary asylum

Becky's blog. Just a Zimbo in Masvingo, Zimbabwe, Africa

"An eye for an eye will only make the whole world blind" - Mohandas Gandhi. Then so be it.

Neurodivergent Rebel

Rebelling against a culture that values assimilation over individuality.

UNLIMBITED TREE SERVICE, INC.

Unlimbited Tree Service was started with one goal in mind: To enhance the beauty and value of residential and commercial properties while ensuring the safety of their occupants. With Unlimbited, you know that you're getting the very best.

chicblanc

Fashion blog by Parisa

Beaches RVs

Beaches RVs offers a range of quality Campervans, Caravans etc.

Texas Native Threads

Uniquely Texas, Simply you.

Histoires de photos

Photographe spécialisé argentique Nord

sanseilife

Food . Culture . Community . Japanese . Sansei

Mission: Loved

Prayer, Worship and Missions ministry of Dylan Raines

Janine Nissa

Fashion - Travel - Lifestyle

SKYLARITY

Mindfulness, Spontaneity and Authenticity

Salt of Portugal

all that is glorious about Portugal

Paris1972-Versailles2003

Travel and my anecdotes

Advertisements
%d bloggers like this: